Disclaimer: The reviews and ratings are based on criteria that our sleep researchers deem important. This is a comparison site operated by DIBMat GmbH, a fully-owned subsidiary of Emma Sleep that owns the Emma products featured on this site. Our researchers try their best to keep all details and promos updated. Full details

What is the difference between a mattress in a box vs a traditional mattress?

  1. Price
  2. Delivery Options
  3. Installation Convenience
  4. Spinal Support
  5. Risk-Free Trials
  6. Durability
  7. Partner Sleeping

Selecting your mattress requires meticulous scrutiny. You need to ensure it fits your sleeping needs, be it comfort, support, or durability. After all, people spend about one-third of their lifetime sleeping. While there is a wide array of mattress types found in the Australian market, many find themselves being torn between mattress in a box vs traditional mattress variants.

Traditionally, buying a new mattress means heading all the way to brick-and-mortar mattress stores and trying out numerous models while hoping you find one that is perfectly comfortable. Today, the mattress buying process has been revolutionized following the introduction of the mattress in a box. Unlike traditional mattresses which are sold in ready-to-sleep form, the mattress in a box in Australia is compressed and delivered in a box.

Between 2015 and 2020, imported and low-cost mattress products, especially in the mattress in the box format, have continued to capture an increasing share of the Australian domestic market. The question at hand, though — is this type of mattress for you? Here is a comprehensive comparison guide between a mattress in a box vs a traditional mattress to help you make an informed decision.



When it comes to comparing the price range, a mattress in a box is typically less expensive than a traditional mattress. Although some mattress in a box brands can come at the higher end of the price scale, coming in at $1,649.00 (queen size) or more, there are some that are immensely affordable, especially when compared to traditional models.

For instance, the Emma mattress (queen size) is only $999.00. Let’s not overlook the number of discounts and deals being provided for purchasing mattresses on a box online. You can easily find yourself a comfortable and supportive mattress for much less than you would pay for a spring mattress in a physical furniture store.

Much of the cost savings from mattresses in a box comes from the fact that most manufacturers sell via online sites. The lack of brick-and-mortar stores allows retailers to reduce overhead costs. To add to that, the compressed form of a mattress in a box helps lower down shipping costs. Manufacturers pass on these savings for consumers to take advantage of.

Delivery Options

When you shop for a traditional mattress in furniture stores, you’ll have to order it from the warehouse and arrange for a delivery schedule. To add to that, you have to transport and set up the new mattress on your own.

Alternatively, when you buy a mattress in a box, the mattress is shipped right to your doorstep conveniently. The best part about this is the shipping fee is often included on the overall costs.

A mattress in a box is made of memory foam. It uses automated compression technology and a powerful hydraulic press to fit the mattress in a small box. If you don’t have help, the ideal choice would be a mattress in a box.

Installation Convenience

Installation Convenience

When it comes to installing a traditional mattress, you’ll need to carry it up a flight of stairs to your bedroom, remove your old mattress, and install it. If you don’t want to move and set up your new mattress on your own, some furniture stores offer white-glove delivery, provided that you pay an additional fee that starts at $100.

If you purchase a mattress in a box online, it will be delivered right to your doorstep. When the box arrives, it is only about the size of a mini-fridge which means it is easier to move. Inside, you’ll find the mattress in a box in a rolled tube. The box will also typically have convenient cutouts on the side for the customer’s ease of handling.

Ordering the best mattress in a box in Australia means taking advantage of installation convenience. All you need to do is remove the plastic, unroll the mattress in a box and let it fully expand once opened.

Spinal Support

When it comes to choosing a mattress, one of the top considerations for buyers is spinal support.

Everyone has different sleep preferences (side sleeper, back sleeper, or stomach sleeper), which can make it hard to find the perfect mattress. But, what’s important is to choose a mattress that has the right amount of firmness. If your mattress is too firm, it will push on your body’s pressure points and cause spinal misalignment. Sleeping on a mattress without proper spinal support can result in waking up with body aches.

Traditional mattresses are built with spring coils that provide uniform pressure on all areas of the body. The problem with these is it tends to feel too firm for the body and causes the spine to form in an unnatural curve.

Fortunately, a mattress in a box is made of durable counter-pressure foam that adapts to the body’s shape and aligns the spine. Your shoulder blades, tailbones, neck, and lower back will be well supported to avoid any pains.

Risk-Free Trials

Risk-Free Trials

While it’s true that traditional mattresses can be tested in physical stores before buying, it can be time-consuming to choose from all the different models. On the other hand, while most people think that mattresses in a box are risky to purchase, their long free-trial periods say otherwise.

Upon buying a mattress in a box, you will typically have a trial period of at least 100 nights long. If you are not satisfied with your mattress, the company can arrange for personnel to pick it up again from your address, free of charge.


When comparing durability, a mattress in a box is the clear winner. This is evident in the long warranties offered by different mattresses in a box brand, coming in at a minimum of 10 years. This shows that they are confident in their products’ longevity. Compared to this, a traditional mattress will typically have a shorter life span because of its springs that show symptoms of sagging.

Partner Sleeping

Partner Sleeping

If you sleep with a partner, you might want to invest in a mattress in a box for it will typically feature motion isolation or zero partner disturbance.

For Emma mattresses, this is made possible by a multi-layer, supportive foam that adapts to pressure and responds to every movement for ideal comfort. You are guaranteed comfort however you sleep — even if you’re tossing and turning at night.

On the other hand, traditional mattresses tend to disrupt sleep due to the linked coil spring system. These can also become noisy upon movement, which can lead to noise disturbances as well.

Key Takeaway

When it comes to comparing between a mattress in a box vs a traditional mattress, the mattress in a box is evidently more beneficial for people that prioritize comfort, value for money, and overall convenience.

A good mattress is one of the best investments you can make to improve your life. With the number of mattresses available in the market, you might find it hard to choose the perfect one for you. To help you decide, we also have a more in-depth comparison of the best mattress in a box in Australia. From there, you’ll notice that Emma goes above and beyond to ensure you get a good night’s sleep.

At just 52 pounds, the Emma Mattress is one of the most lightweight, yet durable mattresses in a box in the market! Click here to order the perfect mattress for you!